Read the full episode transcript
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (00:01.166)
Welcome back to another episode of Starting a Counseling Practice Success Stories podcast. But today we are on fire and it's just me and Miranda and we have something to talk about.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (00:13.486)
I'm so excited today, inspired by
Merrima Donnie in New York City. Maybe you guys are excited. Maybe you've been watching. Maybe he's showing up on your stuff. Maybe not. But I've been hearing this phrase thrown around for a while of like the inshidification, the inshidification, the inshidification of America. And I thought it was just generally about like, hey, things are getting worse, or like people are like taking a business.
business and then like doing something bad with it. But I didn't realize it like this was like a whole theory put together by an author and journalist Corey Doc Doctorow in 2023. And apparently one of the dictionaries added it and made it the word of the of the year in 2024, which made me made me happy.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (00:55.13)
Mm-hmm.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (01:11.598)
about it's like putting a name to the process of what we keep seeing in general with how companies are like flowing and like what
the three stages of this process of building a business look like in 2023 and in 2026 and specifically how this relates to what we're seeing with Alma and of course with Headway and with Talkspace and with all the other companies out there and of course with DoorDash and with Uber and with Amazon and
with social media, like this is not specific to what we do, but it is it is impacting us. Okay. So yeah, so three stages. So first one, stage one, hey, we're gonna create something that is awesome.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (02:01.146)
Greatly impacting us, yes.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (02:10.752)
It's got a great experience. There are low prices. It is free. Like come over here. Let's get as many people as we can. And we're gonna make it so cool while we also make it really hard for you to leave.
Right. So what is the thing that we could offer you? And in our case, right, as therapists, sometimes it's like, look, you get a free EHR, or look, you're gonna get all these referrals, like it's gonna be great, or you're not gonna have to worry about clawbacks, like whatever the pain point is that they create this like, hey, it's like so good. And they're trying to use as every resource that they have to get as much of the market share as quickly as possible.
Now when they're in stage one, they are not necessarily making any profit profit. They may be losing money. We saw this with Amazon where they were going tens of millions of dollars in debt. Like their shipping costs were just completely astronomical. Like they were paying more for the ship for the free shipping than the cost of the good or whatever. So there's stage one. Stage two, they go,
Well, this clearly you know, this this doesn't really work. Now that we've got you here, we've given you this little like bonus or this free thing and it's getting hard for you to leave, now we're gonna make this actually like a sustainable business. We're gonna start changing the things so that this actually the money makes sense, right?
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (03:42.286)
Well let's just d like like clarify that too. The money makes sense for their pockets and the pockets of their shareholders. you're not.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (03:49.493)
I we're not even into shareholders yet. We're not even into shareholders. Stage two is just we're starting to change some of the the things in place to make it more sustainable. They start to degrade the user experience. You start to see that things are shifting, right?
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (04:03.354)
Mm-hmm.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (04:07.03)
And then stage three is like how can we get the most amount of money out for shareholders as possible? So stage two is often before it even like IPOs or goes public or any of these pieces. Sometimes this stage two is what's happening before they s decide to go public so that they can get a good valuation. And then after they're public is then when there's like all the extraction for the shareholder. Yeah. Okay.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (04:10.842)
Yeah, yeah.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (04:31.49)
Appeasing the shareholders. I see. Yeah.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (04:35.278)
Sorry, that was like a lot to just like start with to give us like an a I don't know like a little a little roadmap of what we're talking about. When we're talking about what to expect or where we're trying to determine where we're at. So obviously there was a thing that happened where today is happens to be October 5th. Last week on October 1st.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (04:37.772)
Mm-hmm.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (04:43.106)
A roadmap.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (05:02.904)
People started getting the message from talks from from Headspace. Do you wanna go over that? Since Headway.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (05:06.756)
Headway. Headway. Yeah. Yeah. Headway announced that they're gonna add now this fee for any client that you get through Headway for every single session. Not just the first session.
Not just the last session, but every single session. An additional fee of $9.99 is what you will be paying. Now, some people came to Headway, they had their own practice, they're using Headway as more of their EHR and kind of billing system, and they don't get clients from Headway, but that is largely that's that's the min minority. The large use case of use, I guess you would say, is using it to also get clients. And we're seeing this, you know.
We're seeing clinicians coming to us who are on multiples of these platforms, right? I talked to someone today who does a lot of sessions and is on multiple platforms and it averages out to about $85 a session reimbursement on average. Now, Headway wants you to pay $10 of that $85. Let's say it was $85. I don't know the exact depends on the panel, but that is.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (05:59.343)
Mm-hmm.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (06:20.78)
Going out of the pockets of the clinicians and into headway so that they can do the good work that they need to do, so that they can improve the company experience. When how much profit do they make? Do you remember Miranda? It's like
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (06:36.43)
So the thing so we're in stage two of Headway, right? We're in good for business. So what what I will say is two parts. One is that Headway is valued, their valuation is over two billion dollars. What is their valuation right now?
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (06:42.777)
Yeah.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (06:54.874)
Gosh, that must be so rough.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (06:57.582)
I got two point nine billion dollars and they don't actually like provide a serv I mean they do provide a service, but two point nine billion dollars when I looked it up I think last week. So
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (07:08.632)
Mm, yeah.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (07:09.986)
They are they have this valuation. Now what that looks like in terms of their profit and loss for for twenty twenty six, like that's gonna come out soon, or maybe we could look at through third quarter earnings or whatever that looks like. But regardless of that scenario, in some cases, therapists are talking about finding out that Headway is billing $225, right? They might be getting $175, they're giving you eighty-five dollars, and then hey, for the
For the fact that they gave you a referral, you're doing $9.99 per session. Now, I think it's important to look at this as which is really interesting that they specifically are not doing a percentage. They are not saying this is 5% or 10% or 15%. The fact that they're doing this as a flat rate actually creates like so much frustration.
Because it doesn't matter how good or bad your reimbursement rate is. So in the case that Kelly gave the example of $85 a session, that would be 11.75% of every single session that is just being paid for that referral fee, right? For for that aspect. That's in addition to the percentage that Headway is already taking.
for what they bill versus what they're giving to you and like the rates that they negotiated, right? And then guess what they're gonna do with that $9.99? In particular, they're gonna focus on paying more for marketing, right? And what does headway marketing actually look like? It means they're gonna be using Google AdWords. It means that they're gonna be going doing stuff on SEO and maybe on podcasts and everything. So they're gonna
poor all of the money you're giving them for that to pay to market to make marketing feel more competitive out in the world. So if you want to use Google AdWords as an individual therapist, you're gonna have to pay more to market to compete with the person that is taking your information to market. Right? Now, the a couple of things, right? People will say I like things I've seen on TikTok.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (09:22.714)
Mm.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (09:30.218)
or you know, responses, comments, 'cause, you know, everyone's talking about this. One, if you're not getting a referral through the Headway marketplace, this fee does not apply yet. Right? Just just to be clear. We're still in the good for business. They're gonna keep making changes. They gave the first four states that they rolled this out to, it is not every single state. They gave them one week's notice, period.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (09:56.271)
And they said that they will give other states one week's notice when it's time.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (09:59.679)
One week's notice. Can you imagine if you got one week's notice? Let's say all of your cases were through headway, right? And you got one week's notice that you were getting a 12% reduction in your in your reimbursement of what was actually landing in your bank account. Like how wild is that? Now obviously they're talking about moving forward, it's just future clients, like this won't be for
For past clients or what have you. So like in theory it's just gonna like kind of drip out and you're just gonna slowly notice a degradation.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (10:37.358)
Like a frog and a boiling pot of water. I mean, honestly, like as we're sitting here talking, I think that's why I was like, it feels like we're in the third phase. If this is phase two, no, I know what I'm saying, it feels horrible at phase two. Like I
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (10:55.552)
It feels horrible at page two, stage two, and they're getting prepared for maybe IPOing in 2027 or 2029. I for I I did look it up, but I don't recall. But they're getting prepared for stage three. We're just at the very beginning of this. We're just at the very beginning of this.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (11:02.927)
Yeah.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (11:10.766)
Yeah. Mm-hmm.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (11:21.186)
It's quite squeezy.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (11:21.42)
Like it's quite squeezy and it's an interesting thing because I saw therapists in the and I don't know if these are just like people who are like trolls, but they're just like, What's the big deal? It's only ten dollars a session And I was just like stunned, stunned.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (11:43.876)
Do you remember the days when we used like therapists were really concerned about a credit card fee of twenty five cents to a dollar? You know what I mean? And here we are just ten dollars a session giving away. What?
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (11:52.835)
Yeah.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (11:57.347)
Yeah.
Ten doll session is it is absolutely bonkers to to navigate that, especially when we're talking with therapists. Now, the interesting thing about Headway or any insurance-based or platform-based thing is that there is no like here's the fee you're getting paid, right? It's based on what state you're in, your particular licensure, what insurance contracts your clients are at. Like all of there's like seven.
Different questions that need to get answered to figure out what is actually going into your pocket. And I think that's part of the the what makes it really hard for therapists to like fully comprehend like what is the math for them? Like what does this really look like? As opposed to just going, well, and it's so interesting. We've been doing this since 2010.
Since twenty ten. Like it is twenty twenty-six. It is sixteen years. Like our business could drive. And I still hear therapists saying it's better to fill a session. This is better than nothing. The idea that somebody coming in and paying you twenty dollars or forty dollars or sixty dollars is better than having a session go empty. And like sort of no.
No connection to that space of there is emotional energy that we like, we are not cogs in a machine. This is not a scenario of like
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (13:37.495)
I can't even imagine where it's like butts in the movie theater. Like this isn't just like, well, we already have all these seats in the movie theater. So like let's pack it with as many people as possible and it's gonna somehow we don't need people to clean up afterwards. Like the the cost is the same regardless. Like what we are doing is so specific and there is so much liability connected to it. Like it is just
really frustrating and then of course it leads to therapists doing over 40 sessions a week or they're doing I've talked with therapists that are doing 60 sessions a week at certain points and then still like being like well I can't afford to take a vacation I can't afford to have a sick time I have no backup I have no transition plan if I say no to headway alma talkspace whatever the thing is like everything might fall apart and I might have to
Leave my profession because I don't I've been made to believe that this company is the only way that I can do it, even though everybody agrees. And in fact, how these venture capital are raising fund funding is based on the fact that there are not enough therapists. Everyone agrees that there is not enough therapists.
And yet somehow the fix for that is to underpay an overwork therapist.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (15:05.582)
Well, mean, when we look when we look at the name of this phase, like abuse the users for business, this kind of goes back to that power and control wheel of the system. And like, how do you recognize you're in an abusive relationship, right? When you are and you hear it when you work with clients who are, right? Like, well, that person's
They they turned around and they were nice to me eventually. And it's not always that way. And you know, like some of the things you're saying you hear from therapists, it sounds really similar to what we hear from people in abusive relationships.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (15:44.655)
Yeah. Okay. So there was like I was like writing down notes because I was just like
I knew once we started, it's like there's so many thoughts and questions that that I think we need to be looking at and aware of as like a profession, but also for any therapist, whether it's Headway or Alma or fill in the blank. I don't I don't care what the platform is. I don't even care if it's your EHR. Like we've seen this with electronic health records that were purchased by Venture Capital, where you just see the the price go up
up and the service go down over time, like we're seeing the insidification of just a platform that's just a EHR and we're not, you know, not even these other pieces.
So, yes, in particular for Headway, this thing is optional. You can turn it off, right? You cannot, you can say you don't want referrals from there. Right now, I just was talking with one of our clients who is on Headway, and they said, I turned off my thing. I said I don't want Headway clients. I'm like, awesome. So I Googled their name, and their name shows up on a Google search with their Headway.
link and showed that they had sessions available. Now the question is, is that just an oopsie? Could be.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (17:15.734)
Sometimes it is. Maybe this client thought they did that, but they didn't. Maybe it's an oopsie, or maybe if I'm a particular patient and I go to try to schedule with them, they will redirect me to someone else because this person is not available. We have seen this happen with other platforms when they have given a free psychology today posting or a free psychology today profile, and then the person has said, I don't want to use you anymore. So then they keep the profile up and then they redirect them to
Yeah.
So we need to get really clear on how people are using our name and likeness. A lot of these terms and conditions give very broad view as to what we're allowing for the platforms. They can use our name, they can use our likeness, they can use our license number, sometimes they can use what we're saying in session. That's how they've been training chatbots and these other things, right? So we have to get really clear on understanding what our terms of services are.
Okay.
And we also need to start getting really clear on what this financially means for us. Do you know what your highest paid insurance plan is on Headway or whatever platform? Do you know what the lowest is? Could you look at this cost of doing business? What is that percentage? And how does that impact you long term? Now I saw therapists on on TikTok saying, well, can I just write it off on my taxes?
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (18:48.756)
If you are not getting there's no the it it's nothing. There no, yes and no. It's not a write off. There's nothing there's th if you're not getting the money, there's nothing to write off. Right? Like it
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (18:54.158)
No.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (19:03.01)
And you agreed to it. You agreed to the And so
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (19:06.435)
Yeah.
Yes. And even if you were to get a write-off for it, right? A write-off means you said that you said you were gonna get a hundred and fifty dollars, so you claimed a hundred and fifty dollars on your taxes, and then you only got seventy dollars, so you wrote off the eighty dollars, but you're still getting taxed f
The right amount on the $70. Like it doesn't change the scenario. goes going back to that Shits Creek right episode, if you guys ever met it, where it's like, it's a write-off. Like he's like, what does that? He's like, you know, it's just, it's just a write-off. It's a write-off. Like, as business owners, we need to understand what that means and what it doesn't.
The reality is, even if you're writing off that income, it just means you're not getting taxed that ten percent. But that still means you're not getting that income. It's still not going into your pocket. Right? So like it's still not going into your pocket regardless, right?
I also thought it was really interesting. I went ahead. I've never really messed with headway as a client. Like I've never explored it. And so I went and did like a little search of like, well, what would this look like if I went in looking as a headway potential client? And I was really shocked. There's no pictures of any therapists. And I I think they had me fill out like a PHQ 9 or something. I don't remember what the thing is, but they had
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (20:39.888)
Have you fill out like a full-on like anxiety like different screeners? And then they tell you based on that screening whether you should call for support or go through the process. Before I have seen a therapist, I've even seen a picture. I don't know what specialties they are. there's nothing connecting in there. It asked me what my insurance is, and it said, hey, on average, people with your insurance pay zero to thirty dollars a session.
after they're deductible the after they're deductibles in tiny little writing right and then it asks me like do you want to get a customized quote right for your situation now I have just filled out about 30 questions before I got to this point so I'm like no just let what's the next process then it wants me to create a whole account
give them my email, confirm I'm a user, all of this before I can see what therapists are available to me. Right? Then when I went back to look at this particular therapist, it gave me an option to schedule a session and to pay after the session.
So now because I didn't say, well, how much is it? Now I'm kind of into this connect this this process where I can schedule a session thinking maybe it's zero to thirty dollars.
but I haven't actually given it my insurance information or anything. It's very in like the whole process was very felt a little sub subterfugey in some ways for and I mean that from the perspective of obviously they're gonna do all the like they're gonna give you the specifics as much detail as they can from the insurance company. But
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (22:30.698)
If I'm just trying to find out, do you have a therapist that works for me with my schedule that can help me where I'm at? There's nothing personalized in it. And you're taking me through having to create or having to take a psychological assessment before I see a picture of a therapist, before I talk with a person. I'm giving this to just some random company. I'm giving a psychological assessment. Isn't that interesting? Like
Completing a psychological assessment before you see a person you know anything about them.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (23:00.632)
Mm-hmm.
That is some personal data to be given away. Like that's
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (23:12.608)
And like, is it a HIPAA compliant website? I'm not sure. The other thing that I saw was therapist talking about, wait, isn't this illegal for or unethical? Isn't this against my code of ethics to do a kickback for referrals?
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (23:13.028)
Mm.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (23:28.962)
Well it's not called a referral fee.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (23:32.002)
What's it called?
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (23:34.638)
What is it called? It's like what did they call it? I'll look it up. It's called like a
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (23:45.59)
A marketplace service see.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (23:47.948)
A service fee. Yeah. It's not a referral fee. It's not kickback for the referral. It's additional fees that go towards you being able to do the service.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (23:58.432)
Ha ha ha ha.
What does that mean?
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (24:03.377)
It means it's a
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (24:05.998)
wait a minute. This fee supports our work to connect clients in need with the care they need most. That includes marketplace improvements, marketing, health systems partnerships, support, and more.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (24:15.214)
Mm-hmm.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (24:21.464)
Yeah. Just it's not like you pay us for the referral. They're never gonna say that 'cause that would be
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (24:31.117)
Illegal.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (24:33.428)
Right? But this is the the the interesting part is like okay, let's go back to the mindset of therapists. The mindset of therapists are I showed up and I brought my expertise, I brought my license, I did really good work with clients, I got them great outcomes. Then the next step is what? You give me a raise.
You tell me how good I'm doing. You give me a promotion. We're going in it from this perspective of we're employees. We have a a process that if we just do, if we're just good enough, if we see enough clients, if we if we show how valuable we are, then we'll be what?
rewarded. We'll we're gonna pay our dues and then they're gonna see how amazing we are and then we'll get our reward. Now that's not how platforms work. That's not how venture capital works. That's not how insidification works. I just started sewing.
Well, that's not true. I just started sewing again. I hadn't sewn for a long time. And so I am acutely like aware of the sadness of the fact that Joanne's fabrics, which was like a staple in the United States, is no longer available. Do you know why Joanne's is no longer with us?
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (26:02.682)
Shittification.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (26:03.882)
and shitification because people came and they took Joann's who was a very profitable business and they and they owns all of these
like all these buildings all across the United States. They were a huge like real estate holder, right? And they came in and then they sold the land out from under them and then started charging Joannes astronomical rents so that Joannes couldn't afford to be Joannes anymore because they took the the business and they basically sold it for parts and then bankrupted it.
Nothing changed with Joann's. The the vitrium capital funding went in and said, we can extract from this company and we can create something and then they break it all apart, they leave when things are profitable or when you know when it shows these record profits because they're selling all this land, and then they leave it and they move on.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (27:14.489)
Sad.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (27:15.851)
It is sad.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (27:16.974)
And I think that
If you're listening to this and your heart is collapsing, like just keep breathing and these things happen, are happening, and it's why we are so passionate about the exploration of untethering from these systems as much as we can. That's the beauty of private practice, is that you can create something that's fully yours.
And you get to decide where you give your power, where you give your money, where you give your time and energy. And if you want to get out from under some of this intification, right? It's coming back into your knowing about what you provide, who you help, what sets you apart, and then charging a fee that allows you to do that well.
Sure, this is what these companies do, but that doesn't mean that it's right. It doesn't mean that it's working. It's why we're seeing more and more therapists coming to us with caseloads that are too astronomical to attune to. Too too much. And they know it. And I think a lot of therapists are caught in shame about like, I got on this platform and now I feel stuck and I'm embarrassed or I don't know how to get off of it.
Because the fix, like what he talks about in that book, is like there's po like corporate policy fixes and things like that. But for us, the people that got sucked into the platform, right? The fix is to walk away, to get out. We are not we are not changing the system within you. You're working for headway and saying, I don't want to do that.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (29:08.902)
but still staying with them, it doesn't change their corporate policies. The more we give them labor, it's the more of us supporting what they do, right? And so we have to extricate ourselves from those systems and create new systems that work for us and our clients.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (29:27.598)
But what about Uber? They fixed Uber, right?
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (29:31.31)
Did they? Pray tell.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (29:32.385)
No. This is pe no, people people will say, no, people have have really fought back. Like look at how Uber has been able to create some kind of unization.
It is for the gig workers, there's protections for the gig workers. That has taken millions of dollars and years for the minimal kinds of protections that have happened for Uber in particular states and it is not nationwide. Like
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (30:01.782)
And we're all working as contractors, so there's no unionizing here for us.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (30:05.422)
Exactly. And I think that's the piece I keep seeing on Reddit and I keep seeing on TikTok. We we need a union. How are we gonna push back? Why what are they doing with these employees? The if you guys all wanted to, tomorrow, you were like, I want to like really get someone to come in place. What I would challenge you to do is sit down and really look at all the tasks that you're asked to do by any platform you're on.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (30:10.254)
Really.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (30:35.252)
And see if you pass the ABC test for a contractor versus an a W-2 employer, right? If you are being treated like an employee but paid like a contractor, submit a labor board complaint. You can have AI help you navigate this in your particular state, city, county, depending on how your where you live covers this, and say, I'm being treated like an employee.
And paid like a contractor. This is taken very seriously, and every state that I have seen across the United States, there are very clear federal laws. If you want to start unraveling some of this, you can do that. And that complaint.
You don't have to stay there for that to do some good. Whether you're leaving or whether you're staying, can we can we bound together and say if I'm being treated like an employee
And I'm not getting employee benefits and they're not following the regulations and laws, then can I just submit that and let the government do something about it? Number one. Number two, if we want these national these national companies, we want something to change, then politically, right, we have the option to vote in people who are not supporting venture capital, who are not paying.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (32:13.202)
If you want these things to change, we need to change the people that we're electing at the national level and at your state level. In your particular state, right? We're seeing this with Mamdani and what he did with DoorDash. Like this is crazy. Just in New York City, they found how DoorDash was lying to gig workers and had underpaid them by I think it was like a hundred million dollars, Kelly. They they went in and started.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (32:41.378)
Mm.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (32:43.096)
looking at the data that DoorDash was giving versus what the actual scenario was of what what the people were there. And they looked and they're like, no, it is very clear and intentional.
And then when they put it out there and I I have to look it up, but I think it was over a hundred million dollars that DoorDash had to pay back to these gig workers. That DoorDash was like, Hey, Dashers, we so sorry. Whoopsie daisy. You know, we see, but we're on it. We're gonna take care of it. And he's and mom Donnie is like
This was not an accident. Stop it. You did this on purpose. So like we need to have some politicians to to hold these people accountable, but the
If they're not holding DoorDash and Uber accountable in your state and city, I'm I'm telling you, Hedway, Alma, Rula, whatever the thing isn't I'm not saying that any of these people are necessarily doing anything wrong. I'm just saying if you think there is something wrong and we haven't
identify the and fix the issues that are already much larger or much more visible in your state, then it's gonna be years and you're gonna be burnt to a crisp before anyone's coming to save you. Like you're gonna be you know, on social security because your mental health has declined and you're gonna be trying to get your Medicare because you can't work anymore. Like this is not okay. It's not okay.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (34:18.81)
also can we talk about for a second? I know we've talked about it before, but I think it's really important to go back to this like this aspect which we keep forgetting about or like people are still not hearing, which is we wanna make mental health care accessible.
Which is why we decide to take insurance when we have the privilege of doing so. But the insurance system is really broken. So then platforms came in to save us from the insurance system, right? They're like, we're gonna make it easier. And who's investing in those insurance in those platforms? Heavily the insurance companies. So this is like, this is my my current metaphor. This is like, my gosh.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (34:41.038)
Mm-hmm.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (34:54.23)
Insurance companies.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (35:01.326)
Mm-hmm.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (35:05.002)
We've had a rash of burglars in my area. People are getting broken their houses broken into right and left. This is like the burglar going door to door selling an alarm system to make you feel safer, even though now they have the code to your house. So they're gonna get they're gonna extract money from you in the interim between when they actually
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (35:27.77)
I like that.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (35:34.935)
rob you. And if they set up the security system well enough, then they can see when you bring now we got AI. They can see when you're bringing in new a new TV or when you got your MacBooks. Like they c they could literally have the data that they need. They know when you're going on vacation. They have all the data that they need to make it easier to rob you in the future.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (35:54.01)
Mm-hmm.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (36:02.734)
I like that metaphor. It's
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (36:04.588)
I mean, I don't like the metaphor, but it feels it feels it feels accurate. No, I don't like this situation. Okay, so then what can we do, right, without belaboring the point. For those of you who are on companies, platforms, whether it's Headway or something else, it's I know it's anxiety provoking, but can we sit down and do our math? Right? We have free trainings that we've been talking about with platforms. We've
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (36:06.2)
No it's a good metaphor. It is. I don't like the situation, but I like the metaphor for it.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (36:34.232)
brought HIPAA experts, attorneys, what have you. We have a free training that's all about like platforms exposed that you can watch if that is helpful. And it talks step by step of like what to do now. Right. We have trainings regarding getting off insurance or platforms. Like, hey, I already determined that like what are my steps? There's a free training that's there for you. we have
trainings that are specifically about how to go private pay. Like what does that look like? And we just did that training last week. And one of the things that that came out when we were asking people, like ultimately why do you want to do private pay? And people are like, because I want to be able to be present in my sessions. I want to do really good work. And the way that basically the way I've been trying to do this, like it's not sustainable. Like I want to be able to do this work sustainably. So we have those free trainings that are there for you.
If you've known that for a while, that like, hey, I need support, but I'm not moving forward, even though there's like free stuff out there, sometimes you need some hand holding. Sometimes you need someone to come alongside of you. Like it's okay to get that kind of support. Like we provide coaching, we have our business school for therapists. If you just need to not feel like you're doing this on your own, like that's okay too. But you do not have to stay stuck.
You don't have to keep doing the same thing expecting a different result. And and I say this without trying to shame anyone. We love you and no one is coming to save you. No one is no one is coming to save you. And we believe that every single person who like really loves this work and does it well, that you deserve to be in this work. You deserve to be paid a sustainable wage. And that
If we all leave, if let's say let's say worst case, all the therapists collectively left insurance companies. my god, no one would have access to care. No. Legally, they still have to provide care. But now they have the the obligation of figuring out how to provide that care when they're not pay when people won't stay because the contracts are so bad.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (38:59.372)
they are ultimately responsible for creating contracts and scenarios. And we've seen this again when medical doctors have come together and they have band together and said, no, we're not saying yes to this. The Department of Insurance has integrated in to like bring people back together and figure out what is going to be workable because we need to have access to care. That is the that is the obligation of the insurer.
is to provide access to care. That's their obligation. Your obligation is to provide good care.
That is your obligation, right? If you can't provide great care sustainably and like also pay your rent and have a little savings in case something happens, like if you are paycheck to paycheck, right? And like, no, if I got a car accident next week, like I'm going into debt, like something is is wrong and we need to start to unravel from all of this.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (40:04.888)
I do wanna just add too that what we are seeing work are people who leave the panels. Some leave them all at once because they have so many cases that when they leave, enough of those clients move with them because a lot of these clients do have PPOs and can do super bills and things like that.
We are seeing people who who space out leaving of these panels and platforms or choosing only panels that really do reimburse them well. It's often often not on a platform. It's their independent contract with the panel, but they're doing it in a way that still keeps them feeling safe. And they're also learning to take their power back by their own marketing.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (40:50.147)
Yeah.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (40:56.738)
So, as Mirena was saying before, is that a lot of these platforms are you're competing against yourself. You're trying to market your practice, and Headway is trying to market you too. And Headway has got some money, you know? So they're they're really competing. And when you start doing your own marketing and building relationships, Headway can't mimic that. So when you start doing the things that Headway can't do.
Your practice will start to flourish. And so a lot of what we're teaching therapists is taking their power back and aligning what they do with their nervous systems so that they can leave at a pace that works for them. But inevitably, people discover if they put in the marketing effort.
If they start being consistent and showing up for their business, it cre it creates the ability to leave. And then they end up having to see far less clients. If you're seeing 40 clients at $85 a session.
You could see 20 clients at 170 and make the same amount, even though I don't that's probably too low of a fee these days if you've gone to the grocery store at all. But I'm just saying, like in half. And yet we have this idea, our minds get really stuck on a numbers game. Volume means success. And really, your body will tell you if you're successful. Your your heart will speak to your success, your ability to sleep at night and to
take care of yourself will speak to your success more than seeing 40-something clients. And so I just want to say that we are seeing people leave. It is possible to do it and to do it in a way that works for you.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (42:47.48)
Yeah. And I think it's a it's an interesting time, right? In just in the in the year, right? We're in October.
Insurance, at least in the United States, has is we're definitely in the insidification part. We're extracting as much because these insurance companies are publicly traded companies, right? They're extracting as much for from shareholders as possible. So every year you might be noticing that your premiums are going up in a significant way. Or again, a lot of people are moving to PPO and a health savings account so that they can write some things off on their taxes.
and they're gonna take this high deductible plan because the the math works better for them. But that might mean that they have $7,500 or $15,000 of a deductible before insurance ever actually kicks in. Depending on the health scenario of your client, some of these people are already paying out of pocket. Like they're paying out of pocket for half or most of the session or most of the year.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (43:49.956)
Yeah.
Yes.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (43:56.629)
And so to understand that that aspect, right? And it might just be a really lovely time of the year for people to be able to make decisions. for you to know, I'm gonna only get credentialed with this one plan and move it to my private practice. Maybe your clients could decide to be on that insurance for next year. Maybe your clients say, you know what? I'm not doing any of these plans. I'm actually gonna just pay the government.
because it makes more sense for me to pay for my sessions, my services out of pocket because this is this is getting wild out here.
Kelly Higdon, LMFT She/They (44:35.982)
Yeah. We think that insurance makes things more accessible, but insurance is actually removing the access with the higher deductibles, the cost. You know, insurance is a mortgage payment right now. So it
The it's changing. So this idea of like, I'm just on a panel, that that'll make it accessible. There are people that are opting to not have insurance because it is cheaper for them to just pay out of pocket. And so we're gonna see a switch too in terms of the people who need the support and how the access is being driven away by these panels. but
All that to say, we are here for you. And we believe that we can heal from this inchitification, that we can untether ourselves from some of it. it's everywhere. But I I I do appreciate the book giving a framework of understanding why is this what this what is happening? And so yeah, and no matter what happens.
You have you, you have your wisdom, your skill, your talent, and we're here to help you have that be seen and visible and impactful in your community.
All right, until next time.
MIranda Palmer, LMFT she/her (45:53.708)
So next time.